BBC

BBC Persian website recently did a piece titled “The majority of Iranians, not Aryan race” Dr. Maziar ashrafian Bonab quotes, genetics researcher, in the form of a published interview and brought it to such درتوضیح:
"A group of researchers in genetics, University of British portsmot, under the supervision of a researcher to interesting results about the Iranian race have reached. This group believes that most Iranians, contrary to what is believed, are not of Aryan race, but belong to a race that inhabited Iran about 10,000 years ago. This genetic research that is part of the global research under the supervision of Dr. Maziar ashrafian Bonab years ago at Cambridge University and started at the University of portsmot the result is reached.

What of the title and the content of the news and the BBC picked up is that "there is a race called the Aryan race and the people of Iran are often contrary to the common belief that ever has been, this is not a race and of other races that are about ten thousand years ago in Iran. Lived.»

The most basic principles of journalism require that if we quote something from someone, it should be exactly as it is stated, and not that we reflect our own perception and conclusions from what others say in the form of news or reports.
In this interview Mr. Bonab says:

According to the linguistic differences, sometimes due to cultural differences, religious differences, sometimes twenty-six different groups studied and genetic studies show ten despite that we zbanmon as an important branch of the Iranian language ایندو language یوروپین or ایندو یوروپین is the branch of the vote The central parts of the Central Asian Plateau شهایی handled; Our genetic content is very limited and amounts to a bit of pollen zone markers and genetic indices; that we can find in the rest of the Caucasus Middle Asia, beyond the existing advanced theories estimate based on the origin of the Aryan tribes, early on the plateau are found very, very low and it will show the ten That we have very little genetic impact if the immigrant ethnic groups of Asia Middle Center and you will find the truth in Iran .

Dr. Bonab continues says:

We came to the conclusion that all Iranian ethnic groups have a common root, and that most of their genetic content, more than 70% of the genetic content of all Iranian groups that currently live within the political borders of Iran, goes back to a common root of about 10,000 years ago, which followed the Neolithic Revolution or the emergence of agriculture about 10,000 years ago, in the southwestern region of the country and Iran. In any case, this initial population expanded and grew and settled in all the Iranian plateau and then perhaps outside the current political borders of Iran, and this population is the common genetic root of all the ethnic groups living on the Iranian plateau.

The report of the The BBC can completely through the link below to listen:

BBC audio file

Before I want to discuss the reasons for not being Aryan or Iranian I would like comment readers to this point I draw that the Division of the old packaging based on the shape and appearance of the استخوانبندی, which is divided into different races of human beings * other obsolete today, and not, for example, to the application of scientific research این مقاله See:

‘Race’ and research

Modern human genetic variation does not structure into phylogenetic subspecies (geographical ‘races’), nor do the taxa from the most common racial classifications of classical anthropology qualify as ‘races’ (Box 1). The social or ethnoancestral groups of the US and Latin America are not ‘races’, and it has not been demonstrated that any human breeding population is sufficiently divergent to be taxonomically recognized by the standards of modern molecular systematics. These observations are not to be taken as statements against doing research on demographic groups or populations. They only support a brief for linguistic precision and careful descriptions of groups under study. Terms and labels have qualitative implications.

In fact, the evolution of a species of man, which is referred to as modern man or modern man, has not yet been long enough to be derived from various races, and therefore the word or concept of "race" is generally not used in modern scientific research for human groups, let alone for different groups.

Years ago at the same site about comets The amount of Iranian descent with the affiliate or other family relatives and Nations I published that research under the supervision of one of the most prominent contemporary professionals in the science of genetics, Stanford was doing and there is a word of racial differences and the absence of a criterion called the family to show genetic differences among different groups had been used. And why is his interview in Bonab doctor wary of Iranian folk roots "» ( And not the Iranian race) Therefore, contrary to what the BBC says, there is no such thing as an Aryan race or an Iranian race that we are or are not, but there is a people called the Aryan people with specific historical, cultural, linguistic, and genetic characteristics, and in the rest of this article, I will try to show that Iranians, both in terms of cultural and linguistic characteristics, as well as in terms of lineage, are the survivors of this group.

But we must return to the doctor's statements in the interview to the BBC, Bonab : "Genetic studies show that despite the fact that we got our language as an important branch of the Indo-European language or the Iranian branch of the Indo-European language, we got our genetic content from parts of the central plateau of central Asia, our genetic content goes back to that region in very, very limited quantities, and certain genetic markers and markers that we can find in Central Asia, Transcaucasian, which according to existing theories originated. They were originally Aryan tribes, they are found very, very rarely in the Iranian plateau, and this shows that a very small genetic influence, if we got it, was taken from the migratory tribes of Central Asia and can be found in Iran.".

Because our language exactly which timezone is the subject of linguistic research, handled and not genetic research; the only thing Dr. Bonab can be based on his claims, is the same as our genetic content of the Central Asian region and this is not necessarily the result of clay The Iranians are Aryans. In fact, this is the default آریاییان via Tiki Caucasus came to Iran is one of the only existing assumptions.

A few months ago the article from two Russian scientist about the genetic properties of the Aryan language of the mrddman reviews read this article also last year on the basis of genetic information with different groups, including the Iranians found release. Mention the parts of this post could possibly become more clear to help topic. This article in the Specialized journal the science of genetics In Russia released and backup it can The same database بخوانید.

In short this article is arguing that at present there are two hypotheses about the immigration آریاییان. First گویشگران Aryan languages through the steppes of Russia in the third millennium BC were scattered and آریاییان at the beginning of the first millennium BC from the South went to the Aral Sea in Central Asia. The second hypothesis that the name Balkh hypothesis – Merv is famous to say that the Aryans were in Merv in the third millennium BC and in the beginning of the second millennium BC in southern Central Asia and in Afghanistan.

The authors of the article, then both of these assumptions by bring up the cases rejected. In the first hypothesis it is said haplogrop (Gene group) R1a1 in India and the plains of Russia to these areas and the basis for this comment, there is a lot of people in this group gene is about Ukraine 4050 Years with the maximum and minimum 500 There is a difference between years. And about the history of Slavic peoples around 4750 Years with 500 The year is more or less. This issue with dating guys not in the R1a1 in South Asia reads about haplogrop اکراینی much more than the Indians and the Slavic peoples and about twelve thousand years old, and therefore could not come from the plains of Russia.. This hypothesis also for groups such as survivors of the نورستانیها آریاییها in the borders of Afghanistan and Pakistan are not explanatory.

The second hypothesis is that the migration of Aryans from the Merv refers to items such as could not influence the linguistic structure of the Sami language explain آریاییان, and ultimately on the basis of all the authors of the article to provide the آریاییان migration map:

آریاییان migration map

آریاییان migration map

Based on this map is in fact the early Aryans, first not from the steppe of Russia and Central Asia, but also from the West immigrated to Iran. And of course, a group of them then returned again to the land of the former Immigration.

نویسندگان این مقاله برخلاف دکتر بناب می گویند:

The combination of linguistic and archaeological data homeland of Old Aryan language could be located on the territory of NorthWestern Iran in the region of culture Hissar B in III millennium BC where Old Aryans migrated to the east, south of Central Asia, in the area of Margiana civilization and beyond to the region of the Pamir and Hindu Kush.
2) Most likely, Old Aryans have several haplogroups and their gene pool can consist of subclades of J2 (and, possibly, G2a). These haplogroups are also represented among the Brahmins and the age of these populations is over 12 thousand years. In the gene pool of the original speakers of «ancient European» dialects present haplogroup R1b1b2. 3) During the migration of speakers of «ancient European» dialects through the Middle East and Central Asia, and further through the Volga and the northern Black Sea region to Europe, in their gene pool was involved the R1a1 haplogroup. Later the R1a1 haplogroup become dominant among the eastern Slavs, R1b1b2 – among the peoples of Central and Western Europe 4) In the period of stay of the ancient Aryans in the territory of Margiana in II millennium BC in their genepool could be included haplogroup R1a1, later this became dominant among the Brahmins

Translate :

Linguistic and archaeological data shows that the early homeland of the Aryans in the third millennium BC was probably in the northwest of Iran, and from there they moved east, south and Central Asia, to the Merv region, and beyond to the Pamir and Hindu Kush regions.

Likely to be آریاییان هاپلوگروپهای(Gene groups) They had several genes in their gene pools, including J2 and possibly G2a, and these haplogroups are also present among the Brahmins, and this group is more than 12,000 years old.

In the main European languages of ancient genes, گویشگران tank haplogrop R1b1b2 there. At the time of the migration of the ancient European accent گویشگران in the Middle East and Central Asia and beyond, through the Black Sea to the Volga and Northern Europe, R1a1 haplogrop was added to his genes, tank. Later, in the midst of the Eastern اسلاوهای and R1b1b2 R1a1 in Western Europe and among the people was the dominant.

In an era where the ancient Aryans settled in the land of Meru in the second Millennium b.c.. The tank was added to ژنهایشان R1a1 and later this became the dominant haplogrop in the midst of Brahman,.

About the concept of Aryan as, in accordance with the said دیاکونوف "is the only term allowed the following verses about the usage of ariaiy is about azmanh bastani, purify Arya may namidend. Indian passports (Parsian) And the head of the Medes, and Alan and Iranian peoples and their languages in Central Asia was called ARIA»
(OBO. M. Diakonov.: «تاريخ ماد»، ترجمه كريم كشاورز، انتشارات علمي و فرهنگي، 1380، ص 142، سطرهاي 5 Up to 9, and the notification of 12 Up 17 PS 82-481).

According to what was said, the BBC claims that most Iranians are Aryan peoples from gross conflict with historical resources. Because it is not the BBC's website and not a doctor so you basically did not clear which group is going to be the difference with the rest of the Aryans, Iranians have blood. Merely explained that the Iranians have genetic differences with Central Asian peoples if they knew earlier hypothesis of migration from Central Asia to Iran, آریاییان only one فرضیاتی is raised so far; in accordance with the said that Professor McKenzie Encyclopaedia Iranica website موجود است، عنوان آریایی برای مردم ایران بدون هیچگونه تردیدی مفهوم اتنیکی/قومی/تباری دارد و صرفا منظور از اطلاق آن، گروه زبانی نیست.

We also know, thanks to this very same inscription, that Ahura Mazdā was considered the “god of the Iranians” in passages of the Elamite version corresponding to DB IV 60 and 62 in the Old Persian version, whose language was called “Iranian” or ariya (DB IV, 88-89). Then again, the Avesta clearly uses airya as an ethnic name (Vd. 1; Yt. 13.143-44, etc.), where it appears in expressions such as airyāfi; daiŋˊhāvō “Iranian lands, peoples,” airyō.šayanəm“land inhabited by Iranians,” and airyanəm vaējō vaŋhuyāfi; dāityayāfi; “Iranian stretch of the good Dāityā,” the river Oxus, the modern Āmū Daryā (q.v.; see ĒRĀN-WĒZ). There can be no doubt about the ethnic value of Old Iran. arya(Benveniste, 1969, I, pp. 369 f.; Szemerényi; Kellens).

همینطور به این سند Look at Professor J. Nelly who says that the meaning of the word Aryan has many meanings among Indians, but among Iranians its only meaning is ethnic.

Emile Benveniste is thus quite right to assert that, unlike the various terms connected with the Aryan arya- in Old Indian, the Old Iranian arya- is documented solely as an ethnic name

Darius Kiani, a prominent Iranian scholar earlier in an article on the site azrgshansp Aryan concept in the field of historical documents has collected that At this address Is accessible.